Given his fondness for bloated extravagance in his
storytelling- his last four films have come in at 2 and a half hours minimum -
it is surprising that Christopher Nolan confines himself to 106 minutes in Dunkirk. It’s even more surprising,
considering his similar tendency for massive exposition dumps, that the
dialogue in the film is completely minimal.
The narrative is set up in three lines in a title
card and then we are into it. Characters speak only when they have something
vital to say because one imagines this is not the sort of scenario that lends
itself to banter. The result is a magnificent, visually driven film with
scarcely a wasted frame.
The economy of the storytelling is admirable. We
don’t need to know about the British Expeditionary Force or The Phoney War, or
anything of the sort. This is World War Two seen as a ticking clock narrative;
there are 400,000 men on the beaches of Dunkirk in northern France, can they be
evacuated before they are slaughtered or captured? That’s it – tick, tick,
tick.
We open with a group of young British soldiers which
is very quickly reduced to one, archetypally called Tommy (Fionn Whitehead).
Within a couple of minutes, we are on the beach, under attack, and for the next
100 minutes on the edge of our seats.
In narrative terms Dunkirk is an exercise in pure cinema. The gift of the film maker
is the ability to play with time and Nolan does that by crafting three separate
storylines. There is one on The Mole, an artificial jetty from which the
soldiers are being evacuated, one from a little ship coming to aid the
evacuation, and one from a couple of Spitfire pilots (Tom Hardy and Jack Lowden) doing their best to
provide air cover. This is an elemental story of land, sea, and air.
Nolan’s conceit is that the story on the Mole
lasts for a week, the one on the boat lasts for a day, and the airborne story
lasts for an hour. We however see them all enmesh and finally come together in
the space of 106 minutes. This involves Nolan’s favourite editor, Lee Smith,
using parallel editing techniques which call to mind Edwin S. Porter’s Life of an American Fireman (1903).
The result is a sensory disorientation which
echoes the fragmentary and shattering experience of combat. The sound design
also plays its part with a low-level soundtrack suggesting constant menace
which means the threat is as surprising as it is ever-present. On the other hand,
the sound mix does make it hard to hear some of the dialogue; not that anyone
ever says anything crucial.
The approach to character is similarly random. We
follow the characters we follow simply because they are there, their stories
intersect as their lives intersect and we pick up the threads. The randomness
of the approach means that not only do characters not have back stories, some
don’t even have names – Cillian Murphy, for example, is credited as ‘Shivering
Soldier’.
This lack of detail actually makes you more
involved with the characters, it is easier to empathise with them when all you
consider is the purity and the enormity of the threat they are facing. There is
none of the stereotypical chirpy Cockney banter of Fifties British war films,
none of the noble Dunkirk spirit; these are terrified young men who are
prepared to do whatever it takes to survive and get home.
Although it is ostensibly the story of young
soldiers there are some grown-ups in the cast too. Kenneth Branagh as the
commander on The Mole and Mark Rylance as a weekend sailor doing his duty make
fine buttresses to support the rest of the story. In the air Tom Hardy’s
Spitfire pilot is a largely mute witness to the drama unfolding below, in many
way he is the eyes and ears of the audience.
Famously Nolan shoots on film rather than digital
and the effects are instantly apparent. Working on his favoured wide screen
format he and cinematographer Hoyte van Hoytema construct sequence after sequence
of lush, rich images. The benefits of Smith’s editing technique come into play
here too because Nolan can hold shots longer than normal giving the eye the
chance to roam around van Hoytema’s meticulously composed frame. The
consequence is moments that make the heart stop and others that make the heart
swell. The sequence towards the end which marries a ‘dead’ Spitfire with shades
of Elgar’s Nimrod is a genuine thing
of beauty.
It goes without saying that you should see Dunkirk. I should also add that you
should see it in the biggest format and on the biggest screen you can find.
Nolan is offering a genuine epic to affect all of the senses and this exercise
in pure cinema deserves to be seen at its very best.
No comments:
Post a Comment